Try This Slice: DiMaggio’s Italian Pizza

Its a sweet one.

Hello, Mount Vernon. Welcome to Try This Slice.

This week the team tries DiMaggio’s Italian Pizza.

Remember the Try This Slice rules?

  • We only order from local pizzerias in the Tri-State.
  • We only order cheese pizzas to be able to accurately compare testing samples.
  • We rate each pizza out of ten slices.

Here are our takeaways…

  1. Greasy cheese is always a win with the Try This Slice team. It had a great flavor that you expect out of a quality pizza.
  2. Half the team loves a sweet sauce and the other half tolerates it. But! This sweet sauce won the heart of one non-believer. If that’s not an indication of deliciousness, we don’t know what is.
  3. The crust looked hand tossed with love – we felt it seeping through each cheesy bite. The whole crew thought it was cooked perfectly!

As always, this is just our opinion. We urge you to take on the Try This Slice quest and try these pizzas for yourself!

Average score: