Try this Slice: Big M’s Pizza

Try This Slice: Big M's Pizza

The Try This Slice quest continues! River City Weekend is on a mission to find our favorite pizza in the Tri-State.  This time we tried Big M’s Pizza located at 1313 N 1st Ave, Evansville.

Our team of pie-lovin’ pizza eaters individually rated Big M’s Pizza based on their cheese, sauce and crust.

Here are our takeaways…

  1. The presentation was lackluster for some, but the SMELL was amazing.
  2. Big M’s sauce is SUH-WEEET. If you’re a savory sauce kind of person, keep that in mind.
  3. We really appreciated the seasonings adding on top. Little parmesan, little oregano, bellissimo (*kisses fingers)

Average Score:







This is just our tastebuds’ opinions. Try Big M’s Pizza for yourself!

Editor’s note: On November 1 14News reported Big M’s Pizza was closed “due to unsanitary conditions.” Since then, it has reopened.